Black truffles are prized delicacies in the culinary world, fetching high prices for their rich flavor and aroma.

However, some truffle producers in the eastern US may be unknowingly growing a less valuable lookalike species of truffle, according to a new study by researchers from Michigan State University and the University of Florida.

A case of mistaken identity
(Photo : STEFANO RELLANDINI/AFP via Getty Images)

The study, published in the journal Mycorrhiza, focused on European black truffles (Tuber melanosporum), which are cultivated commercially in truffle orchards around the world, as per Phys.org.

These orchards contain trees whose roots have been inoculated with spores of the desired truffle species.

However, the researchers found that many truffle orchards in the eastern US may have planted trees that were inoculated with spores of another species of truffle, called winter truffles (Tuber brumale).

Winter truffles look nearly identical to European black truffles, but have a less intense flavor and aroma and sell for a lower price.

The researchers analyzed specimens from 10 anonymous truffle orchards across six states in the eastern US and found that all but one of them were winter truffles.

These specimens were sent for analysis after truffle collectors noticed that they were unusual.

The researchers used genetic testing to identify the specimens, as winter truffles and European black truffles are very difficult to tell apart by appearance. Both species have a black, textured exterior and a white-veined interior.

Implications for truffle production and Consumption

The findings suggest that other truffle producers in the eastern US may also be facing this issue and may not be aware of what they are actually growing and selling.

The researchers recommend that genetic testing of spores used for inoculation and seedlings to be planted could help growers ensure they will produce the intended species in the future.

The findings also have implications for consumers who buy black truffles from the eastern US or imported from Europe. They may not be getting what they pay for and may be disappointed by the quality of the product.

Also Read: The Mysterious Relationship Between Truffles and the Birds That Love Them

Black truffle vs winter truffle: how to tell them apart

Black truffles and winter truffles are both members of the Tuber genus, but they belong to different species, as per Greatist.

Black truffles are Tuber melanosporum, while winter truffles are Tuber brumale. They have some similarities and differences that can help distinguish them.

  • Appearance: Both black truffles and winter truffles have a black or dark brown exterior with a rough texture. However, black truffles have larger warts or bumps on their surface than winter truffles, which have smaller and more regular warts. The interior of both types of truffles is whitish-gray with dark veins or marbling. However, black truffles have finer and more intricate veins than winter truffles, which have thicker and more spaced-out veins.
  • Aroma: Both black truffles and winter truffles have a strong and earthy aroma that can vary depending on their maturity and origin. However, black truffles have a more complex and nuanced aroma than winter truffles, which have a simpler and more pungent aroma. Some people describe black truffles as having notes of chocolate, hazelnut, or mushroom, while winter truffles are said to smell like garlic or onion.
  • Flavor: Both black truffles and winter truffles have a savory and umami flavor that can enhance many dishes. However, black truffles have a more intense and lasting flavor than winter truffles, which have a milder and shorter flavor. Some people describe black truffles as having a nutty or woody taste, while winter truffles are said to taste like radish or turnip.
  • Price: Both black truffles and winter truffles are expensive, but black truffles are more expensive than winter truffles. The price of truffles depends on many factors, such as season, supply, demand, quality, and size. However, on average, black truffles can cost hundreds of dollars per pound, while winter truffles can cost tens of dollars per pound.

Related article: Pocket Gophers: Are They the New Root Farmers?